Butta Love Treats logo: a gold bitten cookie on a pink watercolor splashButta Love
Treats

The menu

Big, stacked, frosted cookies, soft cinnamon rolls and custom sheet cakes. Everything is baked to order and checked out on our Bakesy shop.

Strawberries & Cream cookie
Strawberries & Cream
Key Lime Pie cookie
Key Lime Pie
Gourmet cookie topped with cream, a vanilla wafer and a banana slice
Gourmet dozen

Gourmet flavors

  • Cookies & Cream Top
    Seller!
  • Strawberries & Cream
  • Banana Coconut & Cream
  • Key Lime Pie
  • Banana Pudding

One flavor per half dozen. Only chocolate chip and snickerdoodle can be made with gluten-free flour; please read allergens first.

Order by the box

  • A big gourmet cookie topped with cream, a vanilla wafer and a banana slice

    Dozen Gourmet Cookies

    Twelve of our big, loaded gourmet cookies. Pick one gourmet flavor per half dozen.

    Order on Bakesy

    $96.00starting at

  • Gourmet cookie topped with white cream, a vanilla wafer and banana

    Half Dozen Gourmet Cookies

    Six gourmet cookies in one flavor. Our smallest order, and exactly the $48 minimum.

    Order on Bakesy

    $48.00starting at

  • A gooey cookie with a swirl of frosting in a pink bakery box

    Dozen Classic Cookies

    Twelve classic cookies.

    Order on Bakesy

    $72.00starting at

  • Two rows of sprinkle cookies on a baking sheet

    Half Dozen Classic Cookies

    Six classic cookies.

    Order on Bakesy

    $42.00starting at

  • Cinnamon rolls covered in thick cream cheese icing

    Cinnamon Rolls

    Soft cinnamon rolls under a thick layer of icing.

    Order on Bakesy

    $65.00starting at

  • A glazed sheet cake cut into neat squares

    Custom 1/4 Sheet Cake

    A 1/4 sheet cake made to order for your celebration. Tell us about it on the custom order form.

    Order on Bakesy

    $125.00starting at

Lately from our kitchen

Some treats come and go. If you spot something you love here, ask us whether it’s available.

  • Blue Cookie Monster stuffed cookie with candy eyes
    Cookie Monster stuffed cookie
  • Cookies and cream crispy treats in pink boxes
    Cookies & cream crispy treats
  • Chocolate cookie topped with coconut pecan frosting, a whole pecan and a chocolate drizzle
    German chocolate pecan cookie
  • Glazed donut topped with cookie butter crumbs
    Glazed cookie butter donut

Ready when you are.

Order on Bakesy